Getting Out of the RFI Maze

      8 Comments on Getting Out of the RFI Maze

One of the hardest problems to understand.

Amateur radio is full of difficult challenges, but few of them approach the hair-pulling level of radio frequency interference, or RFI. It’s a hard issue to address because there are so many variables. For example, sometimes moving a piece of equipment just a few inches will eliminate (or worsen) the problem. Or maybe rearranging a coax cable changes things dramatically. RFI is a two-step problem: First you have to identify the source, and second, you have to resolve the interference.

Before you start.

Successful RFI resolution requires some preliminary homework. Is the problem only on one band, or maybe when a certain piece of equipment is in use? Does the RFI show up only during certain times of day? Unless you already know the source of the RFI, it will take some trial and error to figure out the origin.

It could be a solar controller, inverter, or power supply. The RFI might not even be in your own house. A power company transformer could be the culprit. In any case, you have to know the characteristics of the RFI before you can fix it.

There is a lot of trial and error involved. One time I made an RFI problem disappear by plugging an electric motor into an outlet that was not on the same circuit as the radio. I was just guessing but it worked. It really was that simple. Sometimes you get lucky, and sometimes you struggle and go nowhere.

Common sources of RFI to off grid amateurs include but are not limited to:

  • solar controllers
  • micro controllers
  • inverters
  • switching power supplies
  • battery chargers
  • gas/propane/diesel/natural gas fueled generators
  • power management devices such as battery “power gates” and transfer switches.

Be honest. How bad is the problem?

In my experience, hams have a tendency to treat every case of RFI as if it was a disaster for radio communications. Step back and make an objective evaluation. For example, suppose the interference is caused by an appliance that is used only a few minutes a day. How much effort is that worth? Be realistic about how serious the trouble is. Don’t feel like every random buzz, pop, and hum in your receiver is a mountain to be conquered. Some problems don’t need to be solved.

Digging in.

So you’ve identified the source of the RFI and decided that it’s serious enough to warrant mitigation. Now what? Start with the easy stuff first. Is it possible to put some space between the interference and the radio? Space is usually the most effective solution. Most ambient RFI does not radiate out that far. It may be as simple as moving equipment around.

If that does not work, then look carefully at your installations. Are all the bonds and grounds correct? Did you identify and eliminate any ground loops? A ground loop occurs when the connections between two pieces of equipment allow current to travel in a circular pattern. Also, be aware that bonding and grounding are not the same thing.

GROUNDING RFI

OFFGRIDHAM.COM ORIGINAL GRAPHIC ©2019

Bonding is when two devices are physically connected together so they both have the same charge or potential. Grounding is when a device is connected to earth ground. Many interference problems are attributable to incorrect grounding or bonding.

RFI

An early spark gap transmitter. PUBLIC DOMAIN PHOTO.

Next, check your power connections, both AC and DC. A loose connection can arc. This is not only an unsafe condition, it also can generate a lot of stray RF. The earliest radio transmitters were a “spark gap” design. It’s exactly what it sounds like. A very high voltage would arc through the air between two conductors. The resultant RF would be routed to an antenna and that would be the signal. Spark gap transmitters were for the most part effective as far as communication goes, but would splatter noise all over the band. This wasn’t such a big deal in the days when receivers weren’t that good and there weren’t many of them anyway. Today, such a transmitter would be totally illegal as they are just massive noise generators.

A few weeks ago I was running field tests on my portable off grid gear. My Samlex inverter was introducing horrible noise on the 40 meter band. I found this strange because I’ve had this inverter for years and it always ran clean. A quick check revealed that an over looked ground connection was letting the noise in. I secured the ground and the RFI disappeared.

We’re not there yet.

Making sure all your connections are solid with everything properly grounded and bonded is just good technical practice even if you don’t have an RFI problem.

Suppose all the connections in your station are up to standard and everything else checks out, but the noise persists. RFI chokes for your cords are very inexpensive and usually work. At the other end of the price scale, MFJ sells a $240.00 USD “Noise Cancelling Enhancer”. I’ve never used one; it appears to be a glorified notch filter. It seems kind of gimmicky, but the limited information I can find indicates that it’s an effective device. For that kind of money, it had better be! You’d have to be pretty desperate to spend $240.00 to get rid of RFI, and at that price point I would expect miracles.

When you are the source of RFI.

We’ve talked about eliminating interference in your equipment, but what if your equipment is interfering with someone else’s stuff? That’s a whole different bucket of trouble.

Back when CB radio was a fad, RFI problems were common. You might think it would be hard for little 5 watt radios to cause big trouble, but they did, all the time. Most of it was due to the cheap construction of analog electronics of the day. CB radios were not particularly “dirty.” To save on production costs TV’s and stereos had no meaningful built-in RFI protection. If you’re old enough to remember when car alternators would create a whine in the stereo, or when an electric appliance would fuzz out the TV, you understand how easy it was to mud up a signal. Luckily, those days are for the most part behind us.

Today’s hams have it much easier. Interference from amateur radio signals to non-ham devices is rare. Improvements in receivers and digital technology has a lot to do with it. Over-the-air TV broadcasts are also in a digital format, so opportunities to interfere are just not there like they were in the analog days.

If you do get complaints of RFI, there is a very good chance that you’re not at fault. Hams get blamed for everything, right? Still, be diplomatic. In the interest of goodwill, you should help the “victim” resolve the issue anyway. You might even want to give them some RF filter chokes and similar supplies. The small cost is worth it to keep the peace.

Resources.

This Off Grid Ham article from 2019 discusses bonding, grounding, and ground loops in detail.

Jim Brown, K9YC put together this very, very detailed and thoroughly researched fifty-nine page PDF about RFI. The document was published in 2007, but it is still relevant. It explains RFI far better than I can.

Rick Lapp, KC2FD has this twenty-seven page PDF also describing radio frequency interference and possible solutions. If K9YC’s paper is too deep and geeky for you, this article will explain it more in practical layman’s terms. He also goes into grounding & bonding and ground loops.

8 thoughts on “Getting Out of the RFI Maze

  1. jrhill

    EVERYone’s situation is different. This article covers a bunch.

    But I’d bring this up: if one is in a place where the outside signals, say AM/FM, etc are so weak that anything at the home site overwhelms them well you’re just screwed.

    The post mentioned solar charge controllers. But the solar panels themselves are RF offenders too.

    This is a really complex subject.

    Reply
    1. Chris Warren Post author

      You’re right this is a complex topic. Endless books and articles have been written about it and no one has yet come up with a “magic bullet” answer.

      To clarify, solar panels themselves do not generate any kind of RF. However, if a panel has a micro controller then yes there could be not just one but may possible sources of interference. For the benefit of those who may not know, a micro controller is a small solar charge controller integrated into a solar panel. Each panel in the system has its own controller instead of raw current being sent to a larger central controller.

      Reply
  2. randall krippner

    This used to drive me crazy when I was still a tech servicing point of sale systems. A lot of the POS systems were flakey and just barely worked to begin with and susceptible to any kind of electrical issues. I had a lot of sites where I had to put filtering power supplies or conditioners on most or all of the registers and credit card scanners. One model had to have exactly 49 feet of coax between the registers because the comm link they used was ridiculously sensitive to changes in impedance. And dear lord don’t get me started on those wireless pricing terminals they used out on the floor! At one site I finally traced a communications problem to a bread slicer in the bakery. Every time the bakery turned it on it caused one of the repeaters in the store to reboot. I really don’t miss that job.

    Reply
    1. Chris Warren Post author

      As you relate, RFI can escalate to anger and rage. It’s not limited to ham radio either. Early computer networks were notoriously sensitive to interference. With the popularity of WiFi and Bluetooth, I’m surprised this is not more of a problem than it is.

      Reply
  3. ethrane

    Another good resource is the ARRL book “Grounding and Bonding for the Radio Amateur” by Ward Silver. Can be found on line at sites like 1lib.us

    Reply
    1. Chris Warren Post author

      I’m not sure what happened. I checked my settings and everything is open. I do not moderate comments before they go live. It looks like you’re back on the site now. Maybe there was technical glitch that was delaying your comments.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *