Getting Started In Amateur Radio Data Modes.

One of the primary concerns of radio amateurs who operate with alternative energy is something I call communications efficiency, or, getting the most signal you can for the input power. A lot of fuss, maybe too much, is spent on squeezing every last watt out of our solar panels, generators, and batteries, but not much thought is put into how well our chosen transmission mode uses that power. Some HF transmission modes are inherently more efficient than others. In particular, the amateur radio data modes deliver a very high “bang for the buck” and that is why off grid hams should learn them and incorporate them into their station operations.

Today we will discuss the rationale for operating amateur radio data modes, the pros and cons as they apply to the off grid ham, and factors to consider before getting started.

The fine print in amateur radio data modes.
There are agreed upon rules & protocols that manage information running over the internet so every machine knows what all the other machines are saying. It’s the same deal with amateur radio data modes. The problem with HF radio is that there is a finite amount of bandwidth as well as a lot of interference and noise that can corrupt the signal. Amateur radio data modes must both conserve band space and be robust enough to be readable through interference.

Also in the mix is some legal stuff. Per 97.113 of the FCC rules, one cannot transmit “secret codes,” ciphers, or encrypt a transmission with the purpose of obscuring the meaning of the information. Amateur radio data modes are technically “obscured” in the sense that they cannot be decoded without special software. My non-attorney layman’s take on it is that since the protocols & standards used in the amateur radio data modes are very well publicized, and the software needed to decode the data is easily available to anyone, then there is no “purposeful intent” to obscure the meaning of anything.

Why data modes are worth it for the off grid ham.
The typical off grid ham has two concerns that on grid amateurs don’t think much about: 1) Conserving electrical power, and 2) keeping technical complexity to a minimum. Running amateur radio data modes appears to go against both of these goals.

The computer will consume energy that is in limited supply, and the entire data mode setup (computer, interface, software, cables) adds many additional points of failure. This could be a huge problem in a SHTF situation. Survivalists & preppers in particular like to keep things simple and inherently have an elevated risk aversion. There is also the issue of having to lug extra gear along if you are running a portable station.

All these concerns are valid but I believe amateur radio data modes are still worth it because their ability to get a signal out, through poor band conditions, with low transmitter power, more than negates the disadvantages. The extra power for the computer is offset by running QRP. The data modes are so well adapted for low power that it’s an unofficial but widely accepted convention that no more than 25 watts of transmitter power be used. Using more is not illegal, but it’s considered rude, lid behavior.

A laptop computer plus the interface and a radio transmitting QRP draws less combined power than a standard 100 watt HF radio alone, and if the computer crashes or there are other technical difficulties related to sending/receiving data, one can always fall back on SSB or CW. For the off grid ham, what you give up for what you get is a net-plus.

The most common data protocols are: PSK31, RTTY, JT65, MFSK, Olivia, and PACTOR. Of these, PSK31 is by far the most popular and the mode where you’ll find the most activity. RTTY and PACTOR have been around for decades. Back in the day they were dominant on the bands; now they are infrequently used.

Jumping into the pool.
It can seem a bit confusing at first, but only a few elements are needed to operate amateur radio data modes: A radio, a computer, an interface between the radio and computer (which also includes some cabling), and software.

Most hams already own two of these items –the radio and the computer. Pretty much every HF radio made in the last 25 years has a data port that greatly simplifies things. If you have an old tube radio or a radio that does not have a data port, then there is a way to run through the microphone and headphone jacks, but it does not always work. Many of the older rigs have slow relays and audio circuitry that was not designed for data service. Some hams do successfully run data through old radios. That’s beyond what we’re doing here but there are plenty of on line resources for those who want to “go there”.

One important caveat: If you have a CW-only radio, I’m sorry but you’re out of luck as far as amateur radio data modes are concerned. The computer can’t interface with the audio/microphone because CW-only radios have neither.

Interfaces demystified.
As in most things ham radio, it’s all about how much you have to spend and how many extra goodies you want. Basic interfaces start at about $60.00 and go up into the hundreds. West Mountain Radio and SignalLink are the two names that come up most often and account for a majority of the market; I use a SignalLink and get great performance from it.

Some interfaces connect to the microphone and headphone jacks on your computer and others go through a USB port. There is no particular advantage or disadvantage to either method; it’s largely a matter of personal preference. Also, you will probably have to buy the data cable separately from the interface. Have information about your radio’s data port (socket type, number of pins, etc) when you go shopping.

Don’t get too hung up over choosing an interface; they are all basically just glorified sound cards anyway. For the adventurous, there are tons of articles and plans on the internet for DIY versions.

amateur radio data modes

PHOTO COURTESY OF QSL.NET

Software Buffet.
Of course amateur radio data modes need some kind of software to make it all happen. The good news is that there are many choices out there, and most of them are free. Fldigi and Digipan are two popular free platforms. Ham Radio Deluxe is not free ($100 after a 30 day free trial), but it does much more than just handle on air data. It can also control your radio, antenna rotator, and automatically log your contacts. I use it myself and it’s an impressive, full-feature suite of software with clean, easy to read graphics. Still, it’s got a significant learning curve and not everyone will want or need that level of functionality.

All of the popular programs for amateur radio data modes have a wealth of on line documentation and discussion forums if you run into trouble. If you’re not sure what software you want, download all of them and try them out. You’ll eventually settle into one you are comfortable with. As with interfaces, this is not a decision you need to agonize over.

Getting everything going.
This is where amateur radio data modes can be a bit frustrating. The biggest beginner’s hurdle is getting all your computer sound card & microphone settings right, as well as your software options and the interface too. Trust me, this can be a rage-inducing experience, but stick with it. The best advice I can give is follow the user manual . Go through the settings step by step and do not skip anything or take shortcuts no matter how much of a computer wizard you think you are. It also helps if you read through the instructions first and familiarize yourself with the process.

One maddening problem I experienced when recently setting up my new computer for amateur radio data modes is that a lot of the documentation is written for older operating systems and was never updated. Most of the screens and settings do not match up with what the manual directs. If this happens, you may have to do some guesswork or dig around online user forums. Free programs are public domain so you won’t get and should not expect professional support. At the other end of the scale, I paid good money for the Ham Radio Deluxe software and was not happy that their documentation is two operating systems behind the times. To be fair, HRD offers free call in and email support for paid users.

Once everything is working, you’ll be exited to see that it really works! I suggest starting off with PSK31 as it is the most popular digital mode. This YouTube video from K4REF is somewhat lengthy but gives a great overview of setting up amateur radio data modes:

Let’s confront the ugly.
Ham Radio Deluxe recently went through a high profile controversy where one single user on an internet forum accused HRD of purposely “hacking” his computer in retaliation for a disagreement he had with the company. As expected, the forum quickly descended into hundreds of “me too!” responses of questionable validity and a lot of pissing back and forth over side issues that had little to do with the original topic.

On the internet, things tend to get amplified beyond far their importance. I was ambivalent about even mentioning this incident out of concerns of calling additional attention to a subject that already got way more exposure than it deserved. I ultimately decided to include the information because this very public altercation is likely to come up in your reading elsewhere anyway, as evidenced in the “comments” section at the end of this article.

Ham Radio Deluxe has without equivocation admitted to the problem, made whole those who were negatively effected, and made appropriate internal changes to prevent it from happening again. It’s also important to note that the “hacking,” if that’s what it can be called, was caused by an individual HRD employee who was acting on his own and not out of any corporate policy or management group decision. This individual is no longer with the organization. In my opinion, HRD is an inherently honest operation that was thrown under the bus by the unethical acts of one person. Enough already! They have satisfactorily made amends and do not deserve to be bashed ad infinitum over this issue.

Click here for the formal statement from Ham Radio Deluxe. 

What you need to know.
Getting started in amateur radio data modes requires some expense & effort but once over that hump you’ll find that it’s a useful & fun medium with a very high communications efficiency. I’ve worked more DX with five watts of PSK31 into a simple wire antenna than I ever have or will on full power voice or CW. The technical complexity and power requirements that hold back some survivalists/preppers and off gridders should not be a deal breaker; the payoff is well worth it. And while the digital modes cannot be considered “secure” comms, the fact that most hams don’t have the means to decode the data does offer an informal level of privacy compared to in the open voice transmissions. As always, it’s best to learn these skills well in advance of an urgent need.

(Correction: On 3/31/17 this article was updated to address Ham Radio Deluxe controversy)

8 thoughts on “Getting Started In Amateur Radio Data Modes.

  1. Mike, KEØGZT

    Great post, Chris. Well written information. I’m gearing up for voice/ssb modes this spring/summer/fall using a headset much of the time. I do plan to start implementing PSK-31 in the fall and over the winter months. My decision is based on efficiency as you pointed out, and also to improve my operational ‘weak-link,’ being poor hearing. I’m hoping the headset helps out significantly, but I know the digital mode will basically eliminate that ‘weak-link.’ Of course there will be trade-offs, like more gear to tote around, but I’m anxious to try and compare the options. I’ll have more to add as time goes on and I test the options. Thanks for this great blog!

    Reply
    1. Chris Warren Post author

      Thanks so much for your ongoing support and your confidence in the information I present here on Off Grid Ham, Mike. Although I did not specifically address it in my article, you are exactly correct that amateur radio data modes are ideal for the hearing impaired, those with speech impediments, or those who are mic shy. For my portable QRP setup, I use a laptop computer. Calling it “backpack portable” requires some imagination, but it is effective and the extra weight/space can be shared by two or more people. There is always a way, and I’ll continue to do my very best to bring real-world practical concepts to the ham radio community. Thanks again! 73.

      Reply
  2. randall krippner

    Very nice article. I’ve been doing PSK31 since I got my general class license and experimented with different types of equipment, software, etc.

    . You don’t need an interface or even a laptop if you want to keep it light. PSK software is available for both the iPhone and the iPad (and, I imagine, for Android as well) that works relatively well. I’ve done PSK31 using just my transceiver, and iPad and nothing else, using just the built in speakers and mics of the iPad and transceiver. You need a quiet environment, true, but it does work. A simple cable to connect the mic and headphones from the device to the transceiver is easy enough to cobble together. If it works just as well with an iPhone, all you’d need is an SSB capable transceiver and your phone eliminating the need for a laptop completely.

    . I’ve made some contact with PSK that should have been impossible, really. I was sending CQ TEST KC9YGN a few times with my power dialed down to about 5 watts to test the quality of the signal going out, feeding a 20 foot vertical in the backyard. Considering all of the losses in the system at the time; feed line, matching coils, antenna, etc. I was probably putting less than 1 watt into the air. I almost fell out of my chair when I got a call back from an operator in France as soon as I stopped transmitting.

    . For normal use I use a Windows laptop with a Rigblaster Advantage interface going to a TS-990 or a TS-2000. I never run more than about 50 watts out. Don’t have to, usually. I use FLDIGI mostly. I have Ham Radio Deluxe but I’ve had so much trouble with it working with my Kenwood transceivers I’ve given up on it. Interestingly enough, I seem to have better results getting out with FLDIGI than with HRD. I don’t know if something is going on with the signal quality or what. Perhaps it is just my own impression.

    . Anyway, thanks for the nice article! I hope it gets more amateur radio operators interested in the digital modes.

    …. Added note: There is come controversy going on with HRD at the moment. If you go to forums like QRZ and other places you’ll find that there are claims that HRD has not been playing nice with people who write reviews that are critical of the software. Reviewers were claiming HRD was remotely disabling the software, even those with paid subscriptions, in some kind of revenge for the users writing critical reviews. There was supposedly a “blacklist” of users who had written critical reviews or who had given customer support trouble over bugs in the software so when the software called home to see if it was a legitimate copy it would disable the program, all kinds of accusations have been flying around. Apparently HRD has admitted that something nasty was going on, that the people responsible are no longer around, etc. I let my subscription to HRD lapse some two years ago or so. It seemed they were never going to fix the problems it had with my Kenwood equipment so I just stopped using it and haven’t really been keeping up with everything.

    Reply
    1. Chris Warren Post author

      Wow, Randall, you covered a lot of ground! I can’t address your comments point-for-point, but here are a few thoughts: I’m not sure what the deal is with HRD and your Kenwood. I suggest looking in the online forums or googling the issue. You’re not the first one to have the problem and there is probably a fix out there. Lots of Kenwood owners used HRD and are quite happy with it.

      As for the HRD “hacking” controversy, I addressed the matter when I wrote this article but made an editorial decision to cut it out of the final draft and it never appeared online…until now. I had a gut feeling someone would mention it, and here you are! After reconsidering, I put the section back in and it is now available for reading. I don’t have much to add beyond what I’ve already said except that I think Ham Radio Deluxe has suffered enough and everyone needs to move on.

      Reply
      1. randall krippner

        I do feel sorry for HRD. It’s an example of how a single employee can badly damage a company’s reputation. As for the program itself, there isn’t really anything else like it on the market. It’s really an amazing piece of software and I used it and paid the subscription fees for a while until I switched to FLDIGI. FLDIGI certainly lacks all of the bells and whistles HRD has but it has the advantage of working with OSX and Linux as well as Windows, and since I have mostly OSX and Linux based computers here and only a single Windows laptop, FLDIGI makes more sense for me in the long run.
        … I never bothered to dig too deeply into the issues between HRD and my 990 because I switched to FLDIGI, but considering that there aren’t that many TS-990s out there because of the price, and also considering how complex the transceiver is, the fact HRD has some “issues” with it isn’t surprising, really. Still it got a bit annoying. HRD switched antennas on me, turned on the squelch a couple of times leaving me wondering why I wasn’t getting any sound, changed the output power settings and locked them, even somehow shut off the transmitter completely which it really isn’t supposed to be able to do at all, all without any inputs from me. So since my subscription was about to lapse, I’d already started using FLDIGI most of the time anyway, I just let it go.

        Reply
  3. Jim Robinson, W5ZYX

    Thanks, Chris, for a very informative article. I used to run RTTY on HF many years ago but haven’t tried any of the newer digital models. However, your article has inspired me to do so.

    Reply
    1. Chris Warren Post author

      That’s what I’m here for Jim. Thanks for stopping by! I hope you’ll become a regular! 73

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *